+ Add Question

A bit of UX confusion when using the checkmark to both signify "complete" and "save"

CM

I really like the app, but I still hesitate when saving changes to a task. When clicking on a task you get 4 actions with icons (complete, postpone, notes, edit).

The complete action has a checkmark.

If I select edit I am taken to another screen where the top bar has 2 actions symbolized by icons only (an X for close and a checkmark for save).

Everytime I edit a task and want to save I search the screen for a save button because in a to do application I assume a checkmark means complete.

Not a big problem but an old fashioned floppy or just the word save may help eliminate the confusion caused by the checkmark meaning different actions on different screens.

All responses

David Trey staff
Replied on Aug 06, 2013 - 17:29 UTC

Hello Chris,

Thank you for your feedback, we appreciate it and we will consider improving the UI in future updates. You're welcome to add a request for this change to our Votebox: http://todoist.com/Vote_iOS/


Best regards,
David

AP
Andy Puest premium
Replied on Aug 13, 2013 - 11:01 UTC

I do agree that the checkmark is confusing, but a floppy? seriously!? :-)
A few years from now noone will remember those anymore ...

CM
Chris Mclean premium
Replied on Aug 13, 2013 - 13:08 UTC

Ah the poor floppy is constantly knocked down, but even to my kids (who don't even know what it actually is ) know that the weird square thing means save.